If you have flu and need an antiviral, should you take Tamiflu or Relenza? The answer depends on more than which medicine works against the virus. One thing I would particularly want you to consider is whether you have asthma or COPD. These conditions can put you at greater risk of flu complications, but they can also make one of these treatments less suitable. It is a detail that can easily get overlooked when comparing the two medicines, yet it could make all the difference to which one your prescriber recommends.
Table of Contents
1. How Do Flu Antivirals Actually Work?
2. Tamiflu Versus Relenza: What Is The Real Difference?
3. Who Should Be Cautious With Relenza?
4. Does The 48 Hour Window Really Matter That Much?
5. Who Is Actually Eligible For These On The NHS Pathway?
6. What Side Effects Should I Expect?
7. Where Can I Get The Right One For Me?
8.1. How Soon Should I Take Tamiflu?
8.2. Is Relenza Better Than Tamiflu?
8.3. Can I Take Tamiflu To Prevent Flu?
How Do Flu Antivirals Actually Work?
Tamiflu and Relenza work in much the same way. Both belong to a group of medicines called neuraminidase inhibitors. They block an enzyme that the flu virus needs to spread between cells, slowing the infection rather than killing the virus directly.
The difference is in how you take them. Tamiflu contains oseltamivir and comes as a capsule that you swallow. Relenza contains zanamivir and is inhaled as a powder using a Diskhaler device. Both treat influenza A and B, but their different routes of administration mean they are not suitable for everyone in the same way.
Tamiflu Versus Relenza: What Is The Real Difference?
The biggest practical difference in the Tamiflu vs Relenza comparison is how each medicine enters your body. This affects how they are taken and, more importantly, who should avoid which one.
| Tamiflu (oseltamivir) | Relenza (zanamivir) | |
|---|---|---|
| How it is taken | Capsule, swallowed | Powder, inhaled via Diskhaler |
| Treatment window | Within 48 hours of symptoms | Within 48 hours (adults), 36 hours (children) |
| Asthma or COPD | No specific restriction | Caution, see below |
| Licensed age | From birth (by weight) | From age 5 |
Who Should Be Cautious With Relenza?
If you have asthma or COPD, this is the section to read properly. UK clinical guidance advises avoiding inhaled zanamivir in severe asthma or severe COPD, because it carries a risk of acute bronchospasm, a sudden tightening of the airways. This matters because people with respiratory conditions are often exactly the group most likely to be considered "at risk" and offered an antiviral in the first place. For many in this group, Tamiflu is the more straightforward option, precisely because it does not carry this same inhaled airway risk.
If Relenza is still considered appropriate for you despite asthma or COPD, your prescriber should ensure you have a fast acting bronchodilator available, and you should use any regular inhaler before taking Relenza, not after.
Does The 48 Hour Window Really Matter That Much?
Yes, and I would not suggest leaving it until the last minute if you think you might need treatment. Both Tamiflu and Relenza work best when started early in the illness. NICE guidance recommends them for at risk adults when treatment can begin within 48 hours of symptoms starting. This is the period in which there is evidence that they can meaningfully shorten the illness.
For children taking Relenza, the window is even shorter: treatment should start within 36 hours. Starting later is not necessarily pointless, particularly in people who are seriously unwell, but the evidence for benefit is less clear. If you belong to an at risk group and develop flu symptoms, seek advice promptly rather than waiting to see whether you feel better.
Who Is Actually Eligible For These On The NHS Pathway?
These antivirals are not generally offered to everyone who catches flu. Under the NHS pathway, they are mainly recommended for adults and children in recognised “at risk” groups when flu is circulating. These groups include people with long term respiratory, heart, kidney, liver or neurological conditions, diabetes, a weakened immune system, pregnancy, people aged 65 or over, and those living with severe obesity.
Oseltamivir may also be prescribed to prevent flu after close contact with someone who has flu, provided treatment starts within 48 hours of contact and the person meets the relevant risk criteria. However, NICE does not recommend it for routine flu prevention in otherwise healthy adults under 65.
What Side Effects Should I Expect?
The side effects are a little different, partly because the medicines are taken in different ways. With Tamiflu, nausea and vomiting are among the most common complaints. Taking it with food may make these easier to manage. Relenza can cause headaches and a sore throat. However, the airway risk is the side effect I would be most concerned about in someone with asthma or COPD.
There have also been rare reports of unusual behaviour and confusion in people taking these antivirals. Flu itself can cause similar symptoms, so it is not always easy to establish whether the medicine or the infection is responsible. If someone close to you is taking either treatment, keep an eye out for behaviour that seems unusual for them.
If you are unsure whether you need an antiviral at all, our guide on how long flu actually lasts explains what to expect as the illness progresses.
Where Can I Get The Right One For Me?
Neither medicine is simply the better choice. The right one depends on your risk group, your respiratory history, and how soon after symptoms start you can actually begin treatment.
If you think you may need an antiviral this winter, start your consultation with Pharmacy Planet as early as possible, since the 48 hour window does not wait for appointments to be convenient. Our flu page has further background.
Frequently Asked Questions
How Soon Should I Take Tamiflu?
Within 48 hours of your symptoms starting, since that is the window in which it has been shown to help most. Please seek advice promptly rather than waiting to see how you feel.
Is Relenza Better Than Tamiflu?
Neither is simply better. Relenza is inhaled and carries a bronchospasm risk for people with asthma or COPD, while Tamiflu is a capsule without that specific restriction, so the right choice depends on your own health.
Can I Take Tamiflu To Prevent Flu?
Only in specific circumstances, such as close contact with someone who has flu like symptoms, started within 48 hours, and generally only if you are in an at risk group. It is not recommended for routine prevention in otherwise healthy adults under 65.
Do I Need A Prescription?
Yes, both are prescription only medicines and require a clinical assessment before they can be supplied.
Can Children Take Them?
Tamiflu can be used from birth, dosed by weight, while Relenza is licensed from age 5, with a shorter 36 hour treatment window for children rather than 48.
This article is for general information and is not medical advice. Tamiflu and Relenza are prescription only medicines and are supplied only after a clinical assessment. If you have asthma or COPD, make sure your prescriber knows before starting either medicine. Seek medical help if you experience worsening breathlessness or wheezing.
Sources Referenced
- electronic medicines compendium or equivalent, Relenza inhalation powder Summary of Product Characteristics, bronchospasm warning in patients with asthma or COPD, bronchodilator timing advice
- GP Notebook, Oseltamivir in the treatment of influenza in the community, UK clinical summary, dosing, treatment windows, and the advice to avoid inhaled zanamivir in severe asthma or severe COPD
- NICE, Oseltamivir, amantadine and zanamivir for the treatment of influenza (TA158), at risk groups and the 48 hour treatment window
- NICE guidance summary, Guidance on the use of zanamivir, oseltamivir and amantadine for the treatment of influenza, post exposure prevention criteria and advice against routine prevention in otherwise healthy adults under 65


