Some erectile dysfunction (ED) medicines are taken when you expect to have sex. Others can be prescribed as a lower-dose daily routine. Choosing between them involves more than deciding whether you like to plan ahead.
Daily treatment usually means a prescribed low-dose tadalafil regimen. On-demand options include tadalafil and sildenafil. This guide covers ED treatment only, not the different dosing schedules these medicines may have for other conditions.
Here are five practical differences to discuss with your prescriber.
Table of Contents
1. 1. Daily and on-demand tablets follow different schedules
2. 2. Daily doses are lower than on-demand doses
3. 3. How quickly it works and how long it lasts depend on the medicine
4. 4. How often you have sex can shape the choice
5. 5. The monthly cost and commitment can differ
1. Daily and on-demand tablets follow different schedules
Daily tadalafil is taken at roughly the same time every day, rather than just before sex. An on-demand medicine is taken before you expect to have sex, following its instructions.
The daily option means you don’t have to time a tablet around each occasion, but you do need a consistent routine. Think about whether you would find it easy to remember a tablet every day.
2. Daily doses are lower than on-demand doses
Daily tadalafil is usually prescribed at 5 mg, which can be lowered to 2.5 mg depending on how well you tolerate it. On-demand tadalafil usually starts at 10 mg and may be increased to 20 mg if 10 mg isn’t effective enough. Sildenafil has its own dose range. These are separate regimens, not interchangeable ways of taking the same tablet.
Don’t turn an on-demand dose into a daily routine yourself, raise your dose on your own or take an extra ED medicine if the results have been disappointing. Ask your prescriber to review the plan instead.
3. How quickly it works and how long it lasts depend on the medicine
On-demand tadalafil is taken at least 30 minutes before sex, and its effect can last up to 36 hours. Sildenafil is usually taken about an hour before sex, and a large meal can delay its effect.
These timings describe the window in which the medicine can help you get an erection, not how long an erection lasts. You still need sexual stimulation. Daily tadalafil doesn’t cause a permanent erection or automatically increase sexual desire either.
If you have tried a medicine before, tell your prescriber when you took it, whether you had eaten and what happened. These details help them understand how you responded.
4. How often you have sex can shape the choice
The tadalafil product information says a once-daily, lower-dose regimen may be suitable for people who expect to use tadalafil frequently (at least twice a week), based on their preference and the prescriber’s judgement.
That doesn’t mean everyone who has sex twice a week needs daily treatment. One person may prefer to take a tablet only when needed, while another values not having to time a tablet around sex. Whether the medicine suits you and how well you tolerate it still matter.
5. The monthly cost and commitment can differ
A daily regimen means taking a tablet every day, including days when you don’t have sex. So the cost comparison depends on your actual prescription, the pack price and how often you would otherwise use an on-demand option.
Ask what a typical month would cost and how your treatment will be reviewed. A cheaper tablet doesn’t always mean a cheaper month, and a daily prescription should be reassessed from time to time rather than simply continued.
Safety checks apply to both approaches
Daily dosing doesn’t remove the risk of medicine interactions. Tadalafil and sildenafil must not be taken with nitrates, including GTN for angina, or with recreational nitrites known as poppers. Tell your prescriber about your heart health and all other medicines you take.
Call 999 or go to A&E if an erection lasts more than 3 to 4 hours. If you get chest pain during or after sex, get into a semi-sitting position, try to relax and do not use GTN or other nitrates to treat it. Call 999 and tell them which ED medicine you took and when.
If ED keeps happening, it’s worth getting checked, as it can be linked to health conditions such as high blood pressure, high cholesterol or diabetes. Our ED treatment page explains how our service works, and your prescriber can help you choose the right regimen.
Sources and further reading
Tadalafil 5 mg film-coated tablets: Summary of Product Characteristics (emc)
UCLH: Guidance for erectile dysfunction
NHS: Priapism (painful erections)
Viagra 50 mg film-coated tablets: Patient Information Leaflet (emc)